What now for Cape Independence?
Operationalising the right to self-determination
Elections have come to represent very challenging times for the Cape Independence movement.
The merits of the argument in favour of Cape Independence are considerable and strongly supported by empirical evidence, most of it emanating from the South African Government itself. The underlying level of support is not seriously in question, with six polls, commissioned by three different organisations, finding that throughout the period 2020 - 2026, broadly 30% to 50% of the Western Cape population favoured the idea. Despite this, single-issue parties like the Cape Independence Party and the Referendum Party have been unable to convert support into votes.
This is neither illogical nor unprecedented, but for those who want to see Cape Independence realised, it is a significant problem - and a circular one.
The difference between elections, where people vote for political parties over a range of issues, and referendums where people vote on a single issue and across political lines, is sufficiently understood that the Constitution makes distinct provision for both. The problem is that calling a referendum is a political act which requires political power - something which single-issue Cape Independence parties have thus far proved unable to deliver at scale.
So as the dust settles on the 2026 local government elections (LGEs), what now for Cape Independence?
This is a question we at the Cape Independence Advocacy Group (CIAG) have had to consider carefully. Not in response to the 2026 LGEs – which played out precisely as we had anticipated – but in the wake of the Referendum Party's failure to secure representation in the Western Cape Provincial Parliament (WCPP) in 2024, and our subsequent introspection about whether anything was likely to change by 2029.
First principles
Cape Independence was never going to be easy to deliver. The reality of this was always understood, at least at some level, when we formed the CIAG in 2020. Six subsequent years at the political coalface have tempered any naivety we may once have had and we now understand the highs and lows of backroom politics better than most. What is needed now more than anything is pragmatism.
When the Westminster system of government became an insurmountable obstacle to achieving Brexit, Nigel Farage targeted political power in the very body he was campaigning for the UK to leave - the European parliament. He recognised that its system of proportional representation offered a means through which to advance his agenda and the rest, as they say, is history. Political pragmatism 101.
Cape Independence is not an end in itself, it is the solution to a problem that has existed in perpetuity since 1994 - that the people of the Western Cape are not being governed according to their democratic will, and where the consequences of that misalignment are of life altering significance. Many, with some justification, will claim that this situation is changing. This presents danger to both sides of the debate. Cape Independence advocates cannot remain trapped in an outdated political reality, but neither can their opponents declare that summer is upon us at the sight of a solitary swallow. In the words of Elon Musk, “With [first principles], you boil things down to the most fundamental truths and then reason up from there”.
In the case of Cape Independence, the first principle is self-determination: Is my community being governed in the way that the majority of its constituents believe to be in their best interests and have voted for? If, on balance, the answer is yes, then the system of government is working as it should. If the answer is no, then we should be using all available legal means to change that system into one that does. The answer to this question is not one that can be answered in one election cycle, it is an answer that must be considered over a period of time.
In the case of the people of the Western Cape, the answer is unequivocal. They are not being governed according to their democratic will. Instead, they have perpetually been governed according to policies which they have explicitly rejected. This is not something they must be forced to endure, it is something which must change, and the right of all peoples to self-determination, which is a peremptory norm of international law and therefore binding upon all states, is the means by which they can demand change as a legal right which they are fully entitled to assert.
Cape Independence is one means via which to exercise the right of self-determination - in truth the most extreme, but also the most complete. Less radical forms of self-determination exist: federalism, devolution, regional autonomy. Which form is appropriate will ultimately be determined by whether it satisfactorily resolves the misalignment between the people and their democratic will. This cannot, however, be divorced from the question of what can be achieved in the prevailing political climate - a strategic framework the ANC have insightfully reduced to “the balance of forces”.
WC autonomy broader than independence
Notably, the desire for Western Cape autonomy is not confined to the Cape Independence movement. To the contrary, it has consistently formed an integral part of DA policy, and has openly been pursued by the Western Cape Government. Comparative state practice, and logic, affirm that once achieved, autonomy becomes infectious. In the case of the Western Cape, even its pursuit has proliferated without having first been achieved. In 2019, the DA campaigned on the devolution of policing and rail. Along the way, electricity, ports, and even at one point taxation, have been added to the wish list. The pursuit of autonomy is the obvious next step, wherever that may lead.
Once again, this is not a eureka moment for the CIAG. We were the instigators of the Western Cape Devolution Working Group - something which itself served a useful lesson. Two years of talking, but little of substance as a result. Its sole outputs being the DA’s Western Cape Provincial Powers Bill, which the WCPP pursued to the public consultation stage, before being quietly mothballed without explanation, and the Freedom Front Plus’s (FF Plus) Western Cape Peoples Bill which stalled at committee stage, but which at least gave rise to what may well become a critically important WCPP legal opinion.
Wanting autonomy, and being willing to do what is required to achieve it, are two very different propositions. This recognition has shaped the current objectives of the CIAG.
Operationalising self-determination
Two obstacles stand between the Western Cape and meaningful autonomy, and I have previously written at length about both: a conservative reading of the law, and political sensitivity around the use of the word “self-determination”. In the case of the latter, Helen Zille, in her own inimitable style - may it never change - challenged me directly, “Can we not call it something else?”
As a peremptory norm of international law, and as such, non-derogable and binding on all states, self-determination holds the key to the realisation of autonomy for the Western Cape within the South African State, and should that prove insufficient to resolve the province’s political and democratic misalignment, Cape Independence beyond it.
Self-determination is not foreign to the Constitution; to the contrary, it is explicitly accommodated, both directly in section 235, and indirectly through its reception of international law. What neither the Constitution, Parliament, nor the Courts have done, is to move the right to self-determination beyond the abstract to operationalisation. If we are to achieve autonomy, and perhaps independence beyond, this is what needs to be done next. This sentiment is summed up perfectly by UN independent expert, Dr Alfred de Zayas, when he said, “Even though self-determination has emerged as a jus cogens right, superior to many other international law principles, including territorial integrity, it is not self-executing.”
Any formal assertion of the right to self-determination would force the South African State to grapple with its far reaching and inherent legal consequences. It would move self-determination beyond a curious hypothetical abstraction, firmly into the realm of legal precedent, and the State’s response will become a matter of record. Critically, because of its foundation in international law, assertion would ultimately also establish legal jurisdiction beyond just the domestic realm.
Provincial motion provides the key
The WCPP’s legal opinion on the Western Cape Peoples Bill provides the means, confirming as it does that the people of the Western Cape can assert their desire for self-determination by passing a motion in the WCPP. This is a remarkably low bar, cleared in a matter of days by the parties holding a majority in that house.
Such a motion could be on policing, ports, fiscal autonomy, and it would force the South African State into good-faith negotiations, where it would have a positive obligation to give effect to the expressed desire for self-determination, whilst ensuring that in doing so it does not infringe upon the rights of others who may be affected. The resulting legal obligation to give effect to the outcome of those negotiations in national legislation, including changing the Constitution if necessary, lies with the State and not the Western Cape.
The next task for Cape Independence in general, and the CIAG specifically, is therefore to drive the tabling of just such a motion. Lobbying the DA to overcome their resistance to the phrase “self-determination” and to see it for what it is - a positive, constructive, powerful, and legally documented human right which can deliver provincial autonomy into its hands - is one avenue which the CIAG will pursue. Working with the FF Plus, a party who need no introduction to the right of self-determination, is another. It was for this reason that the CIAG merged its political vehicle, the Referendum Party, into the FF Plus and signed a formal cooperation agreement with it. It is not just the DA who can advance self-determination in the WCPP - and the FF Plus are fresh off their best election result ever, with their biggest growth occurring here in the Western Cape.
Cape Independence may look battered from the outside, but it is anything but broken. In truth, it now has a far more clinical understanding of what needs to be done than ever before. Moving self-determination beyond the abstract will be our Rubicon moment.
(This article first appeared on Politicsweb: https://www.politicsweb.co.za/news/what-now-for-cape-independence)
